Saturday, March 8, 2014

Makeup Mess

I chose Makeup Mess by Robert Munsch. It was illustrated by Michael Martchenko and was published April 1st, 2002. This book is about a little girl, Julie, who saves up $100 to buy some makeup. She goes to the drug store and asks for all kinds of colorful stuff to put on. “I want some red lipstick, blue lipstick, black lipstick, pink lipstick, yellow lipstick, purple lipstick... I want one of everything you’ve got!” (Munsch, 2002, pg. 6). She goes home and puts it all on thinking she looks beautiful. She puts different colors on her eyes, cheeks and lips. She colors her hair purple and put tons of earrings in her ears. She goes down stairs to show her parents and they freak out. Julie wonders what is wrong with them because she believes she is as beautiful as a movie star. She goes upstairs and takes it all off to redo it. When she redoes it she does different colors but basically in the same places and to the same extreme. However this time she adds two rings in her nose. This time she believes she is as beautiful as two movie stars! (Munsch, 2002, pg. 14). She goes down again and they still freak out. Then she goes back up and cleans it all off. Whens he comes back down her parents tell her how beautiful she looks. She realizes that she doesn’t need to wear all that makeup to be beautiful. She realizes she made a huge mistake and sells it all for $300! (Munsch, 2002, pg. 20). The main character, Julie, was actually created after his daughter who loves makeup. This book teaches young girls that beauty comes from the inside. They don’t need makeup to be beautiful. I believe this book is suitable for all children. Also, Julie is a young black girl and both her parents are white. This brings in the idea that she was adopted. Julie has the power in this story. We hear her thoughts and actions. She is presenting the normal thoughts of a little girl. Many times girls see their mothers putting on their make up and they are just naturally curious. Most parents don’t punish a little girl who wants to experiment with make up because most girls want to know what make up is all about. I enjoyed the fact that Julie was African American and her parents were White. They were trying to teach her that she was beautiful just the way she is. This a great lesson to children because they can see that she isn’t the same color as them and she is also beautiful. 
Robert Munsch travels the world telling stories to children. He always stays with a family so he never has to stop telling stories. (Munsch, 2013). He stays with families of many races so many of his books include interracial characters. “I almost flunked first grade and also the second, third, fourth, and fifth; but my younger brother was in the grade behind me, and he was a brain and nobody wanted to have me be in the same grade as him, so they kept passing me. I never learned how to spell, graduated from eighth grade counting on my fingers to do simple addition, and in general was not a resounding academic success” (Munsch, 2013). He did, however, learn that he loved poetry. This turned into a love for telling children’s stories. When he was trying to figure out what he wanted to do, he spent some time in a daycare and found his love for children and telling them stories. He didn’t write many of them down but when he did they started becoming books. When he is on tour he is just telling stories to children at random libraries and schools. Many times he just makes up a story about a certain child in that room. He often names his stories after the children he tells them to. Overall, this book can be read to any child. I would recommend this book to put on any child’s bookshelf. 

8 comments:

  1. Thank you for your review. I have not heard of this book I enjoyed your analysis. I love books that send a message to children that the inside is more important than the outside.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice review Amanda. I really enjoyed reading the background story behind the author, it brings him to life and how he started writing children books. Back to the book, I as well love how the message shows children that inside is more important then the outside. In this case it was the make up, the make up covered up her natural beauty and that is what the parents loved about their daughter as they expressed it to her when she came back down with all the make up taken off.

    ReplyDelete
  3. What an amazing book. I think since the parents were white, their message to her that she was beautiful without any makeup on was even more compelling. I love how none of Robert Munsch's stories fit the mold. They are great for kids. I had no idea he had trouble in school. That just goes to show that intelligence can't be measured!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Munsch does it again! Thank you Amanda, I had noted it before on the Db post you had written but after this review I am sold. My next purchase, upon a bookstore visit, will be no mystery. He has gone to the top of my list. I thought the sole challenge of the need for make up was a great message but the element of a multiracial family is truly beautiful. I like that you note how it reflects the influence of Hollywood stars on children, books like these I feel push back on those messages from that medium. I look forward to reading this to children in the near future. Thanks for the review.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really enjoyed reading about your story and I would love to read this book. I wish that there was a lot of books out there like this with different cultures showing that there are diverse families out there. There's not just one type of family that all have the same ethnicity. If we as teachers read these kinds of books to children they would know that it's ok to be different and there are all types of families out there.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This looks like such a cute book! It totally reminded me of my younger son, who was 3 at the time, got a hold of a blue marker. I was working on homework in the living room one way and he was way too quiet in his room. When I walked into his bedroom to check on him, he was standing in front of the mirror, his lips completely BLUE! He said that he wanted to be beautiful like mama. I couldn't help but laugh out loud. It took a while to wash out the marker from his lips. I should find this book and read it to my boys. Will bring back memories for sure! Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Awe, such a wonderful book for children. I love how the parents freak out with all the make up on, and the child goes back up stairs to fix her self again to see what her parents say. Children especially girls from a young age need to learn to love themselves for who they are, and realize you don't need all the make up and tanning, your nails done, their hair colored to look beautiful. Beauty is inside of us all. Wonderful Job on your analysis, what a wonderful book you choose.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I had never heard of this book and I'm really glad you reviewed it. Make-up is such a touchy issue: is just playing around with it okay or should little girls not be allowed to play with it. I love how this book really shows that natural beauty is the best way to be! With the media, movies and TV our world revolves around "beautiful" people. We don't value natural beauty just stars with pounds of makeup to look beautiful and that's not right. I love how empowering this book is! I will definitely have this in my classroom.

    ReplyDelete